Can a blog be a blog without comments?
Out of all the blogs I subscribe to, and most site feeds, I can’t think of one that doesn’t allow user comments. I subscribe to a gaming site that didn’t allow comments until late last year, but now they’re on some sort of weird “invitation only” thing (Gawker blogs seem big on that).
I recently came across a blog run by Mozy, makers of free remote backup software. Lack of content aside, they don’t allow comments on the “blog.” I may be alone, but I can only think of a handful of reasons as to why a blog shouldn’t allow comments, or better yet, when an organization shouldn’t have a blog (5% of organizations maybe?): 1. The person behind the blog is a celebrity and wants to avoid the abnormally high influx of comments, and 2. It is some organization that needs to be extremely careful in what is posted on its site, even user generated comments (think church site or something). The reason behind both cases seems to imply a community is not desired, so maybe the use of the word blog is not a good fit.
Blogging without comments is just a website of yesteryear with more frequently updated content. That’s fine in some cases. But if you’re trying to build a community, why would you not allow comments? They play such an integral part in the building of communities where editors and members collide on like subjects. Blogs are nothing more than democratized websites.
So can a blog be a blog without comments?
5 Comments
Orrin Hatch has a pseudo blog with no comments:
http://www.orrin2006.com/blog.htm
He has a contact form at the bottom of each page but I don’t see anywhere to read them. Lame use of the word blog.
For me personally, I don’t enjoy going to a “blog” when comments are not allowed. One of the reasons I return to someone’s blog is to read the comments. A “blog” without comments is simply someone keeping an online journal and they allow other people to read it. This may be interesting but not half as fun as letting others share their opinion.
I guess I’m pretty much alone on this because some of the most popular “blogs” do no allow comments.
I think a blog can be a blog without comments — I mean, it’s a Web LOG, so if you just want to write on the Web, you can create a blog.
Now, do I think a blog should be without comments or not allow them? Absolutely not! It’s fun to read other people’s responses!
I think the bigger question is can a blog be a blog without readers. Or put another way, if a blogger blogs but nobody reads it do falling trees make noise?
I’ve had a commentless blog since 1999. People reply directly to me via e-mail and if its reasonable, I incorporate both their response and some of the answers into a follow-up article.