Photoshoping children looks trashy
I’m actually okay with airbrushing from a design standpoint — to an extent. So long as you “clean up” blemishes, I’m fine with it. But I also believe mainstream designers have gone too far recently, especially when they start digitally thinning tubby individuals or make humans look more like plasticized wax than a living organism. The above photo illustration, by Jill Greenberg, is brilliant in its subject (to candidly capture toddlers crying), but her Photoshop hack job looks disturbingly awkward. Can we at least spare the children? This picture would have been so much better unadulterated.
2 Comments
photo editing is a must, but with Greenberg I actually highly doubt there was much editing going on in post production. This “plastic-y look” was not brought on by photoshop but by controlled studio lighting. She has a light on each side of the subject, one above pointed to the top of their head, and one facing their face. It’s a pretty simple way of getting that popped-out look and it’s become quite popular in photography in the last couple of years.
I work in an in-house studio for design and photography and we’ve mimicked this approach a few times.
I could not agree with you more!!! These poor kids look like they have some serious problems. Like the ole saying goes, “A picture is worth a thousand words!” Let the original photograph tell the story.