A moral wrong doesn’t mean illegal
According to the Associated Press, “The French state and Internet service providers have struck a deal to block sites carrying child pornography or content linked to terrorism or racial hatred, Interior Minister Michel Alliot-Marie announced Tuesday.”
I’m all for outlawing illegal communications like child pornography and terrorism, but hate speech isn’t illegal. Wrong, yes, but not illegal. Unless I’m missing something, it looks like France may have infringed on free speech, though I have no idea if they have an equivalent first amendment.
6 Comments
I am not sure about French Law either, but you have to remember your viewpoint is based on what is “Constitutional” meaning as defined by the United States Constitution, and therefore has no meaning beyond our borders. Governments of other countries make laws as they see fit. Our laws are based on the ideals of our forefathers and no one outside of the US need respect that. The French can outlaw eating twinkies if they like.
@Chris,
Right, I just thought that in this day and age, most developed economies and progressive governments (i.e France) would support some form of free speech.
Nickolas is right. Hate speech is illegal in France. Its a huge controversial topic in France as Christians are regularly tried for hate speech offenses but Muslim are usually not. There was an American movie star (old school like the 50’s) who lives in France – I can’t remember her name – who was recently convicted of hate speech for something she said against Muslims.
Something else to consider – we don’t have complete freedom of speech in America. You can’t yell “fire” in a movie theater. You can’t threaten some one’s life. I believe that under certain states “anti-hate” laws certain speech is illegal. I need to research that more.
It’s actually somewhat surprising; most countries in Europe have very strong laws prohibiting “hate speech.” A lot of it is due to specific events in their history – most notably, the Holocaust. It’s considered inflammatory, and therefore illegal, to make comments that can be construed as expressing hatred towards particular groups.
There have been quite a few prominent “Holocaust-deniers” prosecuted for their writings. See the case of David Irving, for example.
Actually, I think hate speech is illegal in France, but I could be wrong.