How I would imrove the Olympics
Olympics are great but far from perfect. Here are six common-sense ways to boost the competition, national pride, and spectator enjoyment of the event.
- Only one team/individual per country per sport. Why give a country two or more chances to medal? By sending the single best team or individual, the dramatics and importance of winning at the Olympiad would be like college football, and that’s a good thing.
- Simplify gymnastic scoring. This year was the first Olympics to factor both a difficulty and execution score when judging gymnasts. Dumb. The result was confusion and unfair. Revert back to a single 10-point scale, and let gymnasts wow the judges with their skill, and nothing more. Also, let gymnasts change their routine difficulty at the last minute for added strategy.
- Enforce strict country representation rules. I’m tired of people living and training in the U.S. for several (if not indefinite) years but representing another country at the Olympics (this happens in professional tennis too). Seeing two Brazilians who have never visited Georgia but representing them as their beach volleyball team is comical. And hearing a selfish U.S. women’s basketball player who couldn’t make her national team say she’s only playing for Russia “to play basketball” misses the point. The Olympics are about national pride, yet the current system favors politics more than athleticism. The solution: make athletes prove their loyalty with residence before representation, and don’t let them bounce around.
- Foreign coaches shouldn’t be allowed (nationalized coaches are okay). This is similar to number three on my list, but again, the competing talent on the floor should represent a country, including coaching. If a Chinese man wants to move to the U.S. and start a gym, fine. If a U.S. baseball coach wants to make some scratch working for China, not okay. Want help? Send a national coach abroad to improve his skills, but don’t outsource talent.
- Penalize athletes for showboating. “Usain Bolt Celebrates, Then Wins,” read the Wall Street Journal headline after the 21 year-old Jamaican smashed the 100 meter world record. I like Bolt and enjoyed watching him compete, but his early antics (later tamed in his 200m run) were embarrassing and disrespectful. An official reminder of professionalism would do the event well.
- Drop lame or unfitting events. I’m sorry, but no one cares if you’re the world’s fastest rower under 150 pounds, and watching trampoline is boring. Regarding table tennis: while impressive, if we’re going to medal that, why not add a billiards and Street Fighter II as Olympic events? Those are gamers too, right?
5 Comments
#1 I would need more convincing. Has it been a problem?
#2 We’ll have to see how this unfolds over the years. Gymnastic scoring has always seemed subjective to me anyway.
#3 Having some residency at some point in one’s life seems important.
#4 Do coaches get medals? Nope, so who cares?
#5 I highly agree
#6 I disagree. I think it is more important the sport has a sports following in multiple countries for it to be considered. Otherwise the cards will be heavily stacked in one country’s favor. That is why the future of softball as an Olympic sport is in jeopardy.
I’m in disagreement with most on this list as well…
– The great thing about the Gold medal is that is seeks the best in the world. Limiting the contestants from a country minimizes that immensely.
– Gymnastic scoring changed from the old way because it was even more unfair and overly subjective. The new scoring way is more subjective and minimizes biased judging. The tie breaker makes no sense though.
– There’s way more to the story of Becky Hammon. She’s one of the best players in the WNBA, but isn’t making the Olympic team? Also, the rules in Russia (where she plays in the off season) dictate that teams can only have two U.S. WNBA players. This rule doesn’t apply if you have Russian citizenship. Hammon was able to up her contract value immensely by getting double citizenship and now makes $1 million a year playing basketball in Russia simply because she doesn’t count as one of the 2 limited players. She is one of the highest paid female basketball player now. She wants to play in the Olympics, and she’s Russian. Do you blame her? The U.S. women’s coach was pissed. Why? Don’t want to have to face such a great player? Your loss.
– The country representation thing does become a little odd. BYU had a guy who threw discus for Sweden, and he’s only got Swedish relatives. German has a player who had German grandparents. He was born and raised in the U.S. The coaching thing I don’t have as much of a problem with …
– Usain bolt broke two world records and won the gold, became the fastest man on earth, etc… I’d be jumping for joy if that were me. Now if we’re just talking about his showboating before he even won the race, it seems a little arrogant. But, I think he’ll stop that on his own.
– Some sports are boring to us, and a very big deal to other nations. Table tennis is huge in China and in Europe. China is 1/5 of the world.
If you want to talk about dropping events, get rid of tournament style sports like soccer, basketball, or baseball. At least for soccer there’s already World Cup in which the whole world plays in a tournament every four years.
I like to watch the more unique sports, meaning the ones you don’t see almost every night on TV (baseball or basketball for example). Table tennis was freaking crazy and awesome!
@ David
Baseball now has the WBC as well, and I don’t see the MLB halting the season any time soon to send players to the Olympics.
Basketball is nothing more than a showcase of the NBA talent, no matter what country they are playing for.
Soccer. Agreed.
I disagree with a lot on your list. Especially number 6. The Olympics is the only time you get to see all sorts of crappy sports and be entertained by them. Sport is sport. You’re looking at it from an American perspective. Ping Pong is huge in some countries. If anything, I think they need to add more sports. Golf, bowling, billiards, football, fishing, etc. It’s the place to show off who is the best of the best and if you happen to be the best damn trampolinist then more power to you and you deserve a gold medal to prove it.